{
 "body": {
  "agreement": true,
  "agreement_scope": "application state at equal commit index among reachable replicas; see participation",
  "at": "2026-11-16T21:08:06Z",
  "cluster_id": "cain-mr-02",
  "configuration_hash": "9ad62c270187b9e16d2938370457ddc257cdf9849be61253f4319a5738387fd2",
  "domain": "CAIN42/HOURLY-PROOF/v1",
  "git_commit": "214970f39aece1ea74cf9458dd207818f9762ecf",
  "n": 2436,
  "participation": {
   "full_participation": false,
   "health": "NOT_OPERATIONAL",
   "lagging_replicas": [
    "cain-mr2-node-2"
   ],
   "non_signing_replicas": [
    "cain-mr2-node-1",
    "cain-mr2-node-2",
    "cain-mr2-node-3",
    "cain-mr2-node-4"
   ],
   "unreachable_replicas": [],
   "view_agreement": false,
   "views": [
    68,
    69
   ]
  },
  "previous_proof_hash": "4212a356bf95a587a5f9783a6fa976ed3c4eaaa3044ff22b44a552eee2fdf060",
  "reason": "certificate did not verify",
  "replicas": {
   "cain-mr2-node-1": {
    "application_state_hash": "425c24de9cc4d9bcece8c07d23698e8414152bebbea0825422a157422a595ae2",
    "commit_index": 31892,
    "quarantined": [],
    "reachable": true,
    "region": "atl",
    "view": 68
   },
   "cain-mr2-node-2": {
    "application_state_hash": "7a18317103e9a69edaea646054707adbbec3ba5d41f4d5717840ffb3affeb3bf",
    "commit_index": 31880,
    "quarantined": [],
    "reachable": true,
    "region": "lax",
    "view": 69
   },
   "cain-mr2-node-3": {
    "application_state_hash": "425c24de9cc4d9bcece8c07d23698e8414152bebbea0825422a157422a595ae2",
    "commit_index": 31892,
    "quarantined": [],
    "reachable": true,
    "region": "mia",
    "view": 68
   },
   "cain-mr2-node-4": {
    "application_state_hash": "425c24de9cc4d9bcece8c07d23698e8414152bebbea0825422a157422a595ae2",
    "commit_index": 31892,
    "quarantined": [],
    "reachable": true,
    "region": "sjc",
    "view": 68
   }
  },
  "replicas_reachable": 4,
  "verdict": "NOT_OPERATIONAL",
  "write": {
   "certificate_verified": false,
   "commit_qc": {
    "bundle": {
     "aggregate_signature": null,
     "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
     "algorithm_version": 1,
     "bundle_hash": "d86362bd1af65285ceb1f6354ddc9e2fff8fa69be7f98ecb21d77e0832c52761",
     "individual_signatures": {
      "cain-mr3-node-1": {
       "cluster_id": "cain-mr-03",
       "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
       "epoch": 1,
       "msg_type": "COMMIT",
       "nonce": "e624fa513fb440339563d5e098bf9144",
       "payload": {
        "prepared_cert_hash": "0b88fa7abe5cda56291062bc923f1ebd4fab6bd93acb77d01e66212a376e34eb",
        "state_root_claim": "935a389ef81f2f1ca2a4020466b0b0b22f5ad6dedb033ca75a462c7274ced40d"
       },
       "public_key_b64": "vPOGv/TGGTI7aBRc2XdU+XQyetMHKb15z0uMi+tg8fM=",
       "request_digest": "a88726b985f00119bf61557fc7652cef01fe18e7e92fd2a363e4f42b2224b446",
       "sender_id": "cain-mr3-node-1",
       "sequence": 31889,
       "signature_b64": "dfDbzlMWgHDwtFGBq+mGlz15PGSJ+7S4ZUZN/d4QbugGISyHvmN1ZwVMkgaaHSG5Fpd/AXaJ1D3khA69w3unAg==",
       "timestamp": 1794863283.246192,
       "view": 68
      },
      "cain-mr3-node-3": {
       "cluster_id": "cain-mr-03",
       "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
       "epoch": 1,
       "msg_type": "COMMIT",
       "nonce": "9a16aee14b784689916922238791b300",
       "payload": {
        "prepared_cert_hash": "3467bcbadb06c3c70d28f78e4483f7a4021756be36b07325851355fd4ee0ad55",
        "state_root_claim": "935a389ef81f2f1ca2a4020466b0b0b22f5ad6dedb033ca75a462c7274ced40d"
       },
       "public_key_b64": "JANA5cD7bKzbGHk8H58XkPbKdzpPhZILxLRoDndWtfs=",
       "request_digest": "a88726b985f00119bf61557fc7652cef01fe18e7e92fd2a363e4f42b2224b446",
       "sender_id": "cain-mr3-node-3",
       "sequence": 31889,
       "signature_b64": "EhrDehX7UPMxUbTsfZgmsNdokwieOLLhAJFjxmAZlk7WY+yiSHWRozZC1xpnxikn6yvsn5N6gCIjBsCqLPu1Aw==",
       "timestamp": 1794863283.260221,
       "view": 68
      },
      "cain-mr3-node-4": {
       "cluster_id": "cain-mr-03",
       "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
       "epoch": 1,
       "msg_type": "COMMIT",
       "nonce": "e261e38d6fae43e08c91a41b44e064a9",
       "payload": {
        "prepared_cert_hash": "3467bcbadb06c3c70d28f78e4483f7a4021756be36b07325851355fd4ee0ad55",
        "state_root_claim": "935a389ef81f2f1ca2a4020466b0b0b22f5ad6dedb033ca75a462c7274ced40d"
       },
       "public_key_b64": "vHoUmONeUf5v45rJ1lB4fwOLK/VIhDbjzlXoVNEW2Xk=",
       "request_digest": "a88726b985f00119bf61557fc7652cef01fe18e7e92fd2a363e4f42b2224b446",
       "sender_id": "cain-mr3-node-4",
       "sequence": 31889,
       "signature_b64": "wGZtPL6+vstdv5MfMst6Wo8bvpzaZ4/0yJNuBdka0wYr88bJaCVxwZp/0+X2bsJagE+TZq1p8WepnDmFr20uDw==",
       "timestamp": 1794863283.2451916,
       "view": 68
      }
     },
     "signer_set": [
      "cain-mr3-node-1",
      "cain-mr3-node-3",
      "cain-mr3-node-4"
     ]
    },
    "bundle_hash": "d86362bd1af65285ceb1f6354ddc9e2fff8fa69be7f98ecb21d77e0832c52761",
    "certificate_hash": "9821a0bbe61523f7e5676df18d10d6161e92762a3b6c145a5eb74965498c18f8",
    "certificate_type": "COMMIT_QC",
    "cluster_id": "cain-mr-03",
    "configuration_hash": "296593666ffe16deff7313988360d01d35799c628d4e1e953e070a5d502ff4f3",
    "decision_hash": "8e2da3f6c7b4f3a9355fa4fc183b18eb679d9360849134f12e78ef7ad28686d9",
    "epoch": 1,
    "leader_proposal": null,
    "leader_proposal_digest": null,
    "parent_decision_hash": "552d5627e39114c93eaf186e307ecb2a7508fea4b658ab03907af92058f9e8e1",
    "proposal_digest": "a88726b985f00119bf61557fc7652cef01fe18e7e92fd2a363e4f42b2224b446",
    "quorum": 3,
    "quorum_policy": {
     "f": 1,
     "n": 4,
     "quorum": 3,
     "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
    },
    "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
    "sequence": 31889,
    "signer_set": [
     "cain-mr3-node-1",
     "cain-mr3-node-3",
     "cain-mr3-node-4"
    ],
    "view": 68
   },
   "committed": true,
   "entry_replica": "cain-mr2-node-1",
   "prepare_qc": {
    "bundle": {
     "aggregate_signature": null,
     "aggregation_algorithm": "ed25519-individual",
     "algorithm_version": 1,
     "bundle_hash": "11f3db09c7d8396881958ec1828264630a011aff123504ab786237bd754e6c59",
     "individual_signatures": {
      "cain-mr3-node-1": {
       "cluster_id": "cain-mr-03",
       "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
       "epoch": 1,
       "msg_type": "PREPARE",
       "nonce": "3321256a33304f5ca84c940936306686",
       "payload": {
        "pre_prepare": {
         "cluster_id": "cain-mr-03",
         "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
         "epoch": 1,
         "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
         "nonce": "51fba3dc28df4a3a92e5d752b5ecf329",
         "payload": {
          "client_id": "hourly-proof",
          "operation": {
           "action": "write",
           "data": {
            "proof": 2436
           },
           "resource": "hourly/hourly-20261116T210803Z"
          },
          "request_id": "hourly-20261116T210803Z",
          "requested_authority": "standard"
         },
         "public_key_b64": "vPOGv/TGGTI7aBRc2XdU+XQyetMHKb15z0uMi+tg8fM=",
         "request_digest": "a88726b985f00119bf61557fc7652cef01fe18e7e92fd2a363e4f42b2224b446",
         "sender_id": "cain-mr3-node-1",
         "sequence": 31889,
         "signature_b64": "RWCNG3oR7eIcUo6N0B8gDFk06wfv1vOlm/9dX2z3BnHpSPRzKS+/lqJ7h4x16LFKwc/8WjoJvSnCIoGTFYdHBA==",
         "timestamp": 1794863283.1141987,
         "view": 68
        }
       },
       "public_key_b64": "vPOGv/TGGTI7aBRc2XdU+XQyetMHKb15z0uMi+tg8fM=",
       "request_digest": "a88726b985f00119bf61557fc7652cef01fe18e7e92fd2a363e4f42b2224b446",
       "sender_id": "cain-mr3-node-1",
       "sequence": 31889,
       "signature_b64": "+xQQxWRVr0sE73YH5jqJilubVHGxJO8y5q15IwjSYRO32E1pXtUjikI8u7lZkHP7e/fgQdMF/ReoK8C6txdECg==",
       "timestamp": 1794863283.1271675,
       "view": 68
      },
      "cain-mr3-node-3": {
       "cluster_id": "cain-mr-03",
       "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
       "epoch": 1,
       "msg_type": "PREPARE",
       "nonce": "1c275bc5145647cb82b8e206a37d0ae9",
       "payload": {
        "pre_prepare": {
         "cluster_id": "cain-mr-03",
         "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
         "epoch": 1,
         "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
         "nonce": "51fba3dc28df4a3a92e5d752b5ecf329",
         "payload": {
          "client_id": "hourly-proof",
          "operation": {
           "action": "write",
           "data": {
            "proof": 2436
           },
           "resource": "hourly/hourly-20261116T210803Z"
          },
          "request_id": "hourly-20261116T210803Z",
          "requested_authority": "standard"
         },
         "public_key_b64": "vPOGv/TGGTI7aBRc2XdU+XQyetMHKb15z0uMi+tg8fM=",
         "request_digest": "a88726b985f00119bf61557fc7652cef01fe18e7e92fd2a363e4f42b2224b446",
         "sender_id": "cain-mr3-node-1",
         "sequence": 31889,
         "signature_b64": "RWCNG3oR7eIcUo6N0B8gDFk06wfv1vOlm/9dX2z3BnHpSPRzKS+/lqJ7h4x16LFKwc/8WjoJvSnCIoGTFYdHBA==",
         "timestamp": 1794863283.1141987,
         "view": 68
        },
        "pre_prepare_digest": "d163312892259483b572a9cb0ce00986d1e1d641819053553e22c12350ea79d6"
       },
       "public_key_b64": "JANA5cD7bKzbGHk8H58XkPbKdzpPhZILxLRoDndWtfs=",
       "request_digest": "a88726b985f00119bf61557fc7652cef01fe18e7e92fd2a363e4f42b2224b446",
       "sender_id": "cain-mr3-node-3",
       "sequence": 31889,
       "signature_b64": "/m0pD0wORf19YcufEeOKJsROVhYdqJ4alTzOOUXfXFhmad/nSVpQnNOT9bZ95ef3H0e8H+P4Ay8R26tTf7/FAg==",
       "timestamp": 1794863283.1788971,
       "view": 68
      },
      "cain-mr3-node-4": {
       "cluster_id": "cain-mr-03",
       "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
       "epoch": 1,
       "msg_type": "PREPARE",
       "nonce": "438d350bd3b84cb386c133bd2c47d17c",
       "payload": {
        "pre_prepare": {
         "cluster_id": "cain-mr-03",
         "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
         "epoch": 1,
         "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
         "nonce": "51fba3dc28df4a3a92e5d752b5ecf329",
         "payload": {
          "client_id": "hourly-proof",
          "operation": {
           "action": "write",
           "data": {
            "proof": 2436
           },
           "resource": "hourly/hourly-20261116T210803Z"
          },
          "request_id": "hourly-20261116T210803Z",
          "requested_authority": "standard"
         },
         "public_key_b64": "vPOGv/TGGTI7aBRc2XdU+XQyetMHKb15z0uMi+tg8fM=",
         "request_digest": "a88726b985f00119bf61557fc7652cef01fe18e7e92fd2a363e4f42b2224b446",
         "sender_id": "cain-mr3-node-1",
         "sequence": 31889,
         "signature_b64": "RWCNG3oR7eIcUo6N0B8gDFk06wfv1vOlm/9dX2z3BnHpSPRzKS+/lqJ7h4x16LFKwc/8WjoJvSnCIoGTFYdHBA==",
         "timestamp": 1794863283.1141987,
         "view": 68
        },
        "pre_prepare_digest": "d163312892259483b572a9cb0ce00986d1e1d641819053553e22c12350ea79d6"
       },
       "public_key_b64": "vHoUmONeUf5v45rJ1lB4fwOLK/VIhDbjzlXoVNEW2Xk=",
       "request_digest": "a88726b985f00119bf61557fc7652cef01fe18e7e92fd2a363e4f42b2224b446",
       "sender_id": "cain-mr3-node-4",
       "sequence": 31889,
       "signature_b64": "vQDAa6lHlxkNHkeDpohwt65mc4RpX+YFS1rcYaWtriqXadzUXDFau9+g5h0lpOGkkafugCZqKy+mPdyJq5vJCQ==",
       "timestamp": 1794863283.1909122,
       "view": 68
      }
     },
     "signer_set": [
      "cain-mr3-node-1",
      "cain-mr3-node-3",
      "cain-mr3-node-4"
     ]
    },
    "bundle_hash": "11f3db09c7d8396881958ec1828264630a011aff123504ab786237bd754e6c59",
    "certificate_hash": "f0b79b064c5576f908bb6c74c4305c7f75e96c8c66414af79f2f1d72fcc7373a",
    "certificate_type": "PREPARE_QC",
    "cluster_id": "cain-mr-03",
    "configuration_hash": "296593666ffe16deff7313988360d01d35799c628d4e1e953e070a5d502ff4f3",
    "decision_hash": "8e2da3f6c7b4f3a9355fa4fc183b18eb679d9360849134f12e78ef7ad28686d9",
    "epoch": 1,
    "leader_proposal": {
     "cluster_id": "cain-mr-03",
     "engine_version": "33.4-production-hardened",
     "epoch": 1,
     "msg_type": "PRE_PREPARE",
     "nonce": "51fba3dc28df4a3a92e5d752b5ecf329",
     "payload": {
      "client_id": "hourly-proof",
      "operation": {
       "action": "write",
       "data": {
        "proof": 2436
       },
       "resource": "hourly/hourly-20261116T210803Z"
      },
      "request_id": "hourly-20261116T210803Z",
      "requested_authority": "standard"
     },
     "public_key_b64": "vPOGv/TGGTI7aBRc2XdU+XQyetMHKb15z0uMi+tg8fM=",
     "request_digest": "a88726b985f00119bf61557fc7652cef01fe18e7e92fd2a363e4f42b2224b446",
     "sender_id": "cain-mr3-node-1",
     "sequence": 31889,
     "signature_b64": "RWCNG3oR7eIcUo6N0B8gDFk06wfv1vOlm/9dX2z3BnHpSPRzKS+/lqJ7h4x16LFKwc/8WjoJvSnCIoGTFYdHBA==",
     "timestamp": 1794863283.1141987,
     "view": 68
    },
    "leader_proposal_digest": "d163312892259483b572a9cb0ce00986d1e1d641819053553e22c12350ea79d6",
    "parent_decision_hash": "552d5627e39114c93eaf186e307ecb2a7508fea4b658ab03907af92058f9e8e1",
    "proposal_digest": "a88726b985f00119bf61557fc7652cef01fe18e7e92fd2a363e4f42b2224b446",
    "quorum": 3,
    "quorum_policy": {
     "f": 1,
     "n": 4,
     "quorum": 3,
     "rule": "ceil((N+f+1)/2)"
    },
    "quorum_policy_hash": "13d05661a0b1d519909ca36ee4c21be59adc1384a0a7da6d906dc5248e86130c",
    "sequence": 31889,
    "signer_set": [
     "cain-mr3-node-1",
     "cain-mr3-node-3",
     "cain-mr3-node-4"
    ],
    "view": 68
   },
   "request_id": "hourly-20261116T210803Z",
   "sequence": 31889,
   "signer_regions": [],
   "signers": [
    "cain-mr3-node-1",
    "cain-mr3-node-3",
    "cain-mr3-node-4"
   ],
   "verify_detail": "wrong cluster or epoch"
  }
 },
 "evidence_root_signature_b64": "gZBrRHcSS5YZjZqaZhkNNtjKZuZ6c/y3b5P+8Pp4jWlIYcnUaSuobRw/u1C/WUHzCo1MbIYDjd5OjpDjI5ZgBA==",
 "proof_hash": "fb658abaceba97117ee2f08aeb626286ae7f39269b0403af8c5541830d66fd1e"
}